A 2012 Recap and Look to the Future

We expected the real estate market to start to shift in 2012, unfortunately, things have remained stagnant.  ISG forecasted back in March that early year figures pointed towards a shift in the real estate market. Early spring numbers showed a record number of mortgage applications filed and mortgages issued.  According to the Czech Statitstical Office (CSA) however, the number of real estate transactions is actually down 18% in 2012.  This leads us to believe banks have processed more refinancing applications versus new mortgages as well as tightened their belts on lending to new customers.  In addition, Hypotecni Banka has released its newest property price index based on the mortgage applications which passed through their doors.  The index shows that overall property prices throughout all of Prague are down 2% for 2012 (http://www.hyposvet.cz/hb-index).

Things in the Czech Republic are certainly not merry.  The CSA also released real wage figures through Q3.  Currently inflation is outpacing wage growth and Czechs actually saw their real wages decrease 1.8% in Q3.  The Czech National Bank (CNB) recognized the problem and voted to decrease the base interest rate to 0.5% in hopes of convincing locals to invest.  At this time the culture of saving and not spending continues to dominate the Czech mentality.  According to Deloitte, the vacancy rates in Prague continue to slowly decline but a number of new projects set to be completed in 2013 may very well oversaturate the market.

The CNB is forecasting a slight decrease in property prices across all of the Czech Republic in 2013.  This is not a major surprise as unemployment, exports and a decreasing currency  dominate CNB’s macroeconomic concerns.  Looking at Prague in isolation, Reality Morava has recorded increasing sales prices since August. This conforms with ISG’s belief that Prague prices have hit their lowest levels.  We expect demand for studio and one bedroom flats to continue to be the most sought after property as more and more locals purchase their first home.  We understand the hesitation investors may have.  You want to see more positivity before investing but we continue to believe Prague is the greatest buyers market an investor will find in central and eastern Europe.

Preliminary 2013 Tax Plan and How It Affects Investors

1. Increase in Real Estate Transfer Tax

Of several proposals, the increase of transfer tax from 3 to 4% directly affects invetsors. Very simply, anyone who sells their property in 2013 would pay an extra 1% in tax to the government. There was a discussion about the buyer and not the seller being responsible, but either way 1% more money is lost in the transaction to government coffers.

2. VAT Changes

As we discussed earlier in the year, the original plan was to unite VAT at 17.5% in January. The main affect would be the knock-on increase in 2nd hand flat prices from new ones once again. This year we have seen little impact due to developers absorbing the costs. The concept also means that VAT will reduce on new flats and houses over 120m2 and could have the knock-on effect of bringing like-for-like second hand prices down. The government is also considering other VAT options, including keeping the current arrangement.

3. Increase in Share Dividend Tax

This tax only affects those who own through an SRO, but it could be a significant affect. There is a bill to increase dividend tax from 15% to 35% for foreign SRO owners. This is to do with removing money from the SRO after sale. We strongly advise all SRO clients to switch to personal ownership anyway and this further backs up our advice. If you own through an SRO and would like free tax advice from us, please contact us. The savings are normally very high.

4. EXCLUDED – Health and Social Insurance Contributions on Rental Income

This is a real blessing.

The government were considering making rental income from the Czech Republic subject to health and social insurance contributions from January. Currently rental income is only subject to income tax, but new laws could see rental income treated like self-employment income. This would mean contributions into health and social insurances to the value of 9% of rental income.

All self-employed people in the Czech Republic currently have to pay around 9% of their taxable income in health and social insurances. There are even minimum contributions of around 3.533Kc per month in, regardless of how little is earned. If the bill were passed in the future it would see even those with low rental incomes be subject to a minimum contribution of 3.533Kc. Clearly this would make buy-to-let property untenable for foreign investors, which is what why it was scrapped.

Conclusion

The Czech government is doing what it can to reduce its budget deficit by raising taxes. Fortunately not too many affect foreign investors. The major losers will be those who own property through an SRO and as we have recommended they should seek tax advice and move to personal ownership. Elsewhere a 1% rise in transfer tax is tolerable, especially as it is from likely sales profits. The good news is what is not in there; there is still no gains tax after 5 years and most rental income is tax free. Long may it continue!

City Hall Looks To Private Investment For Public Projects

For the first time Prague City Hall has looked at enticing foreign investors to complete many of its infrastructure projects. With reduction in European funding Prague’s major projects have been laying stagnant. The half-built metro extension to the airport is a notable casualty. The project is dormant and well behind its estimated completion date.

The local government sees a solution in offering bonds in exchange for investment. With the economy and banking sector relatively strong this could be an excellent proposal for investors. Their will be some fear, however, based on similar bond offerings in other countries.

Investment would allow for the completion of the hallowed airport metro link. This not only would improve transit times to the airport, but also provide a metro link to areas en-route to the airport in Prague 6. This would make the area even more sought-after than current. If investment was continued we could also see the planned D-Line metro come to fruition. This would link other areas to the Metro network and again influence house prices positively in the affected areas.

Prague To Be New Safe Haven?

Right now many international investors have been looking into German real-estate. Berlin is extremely popular, especially with its relatively cheap property and strong rental culture. At the end of October, major German banks stopped providing high-LTV mortgages to foreign investors. Most potential investors need to stump up 40% of the property price – something which is causing them to look at neighbouring countries.

The German economy has been seen as the euro-zone’s safety net. As a result many international investors have been looking to add German investments to their portfolios. Real estate has been an area where many have invested, but now there is a struggle to get leverage.

With the Czech economy heavily allied to the German economy, it makes sense that investors are looking at options there. Although Prague may not be booming in the same way as Berlin, the market is moving positively north. With everything pointing to excellent long-term growth, the Czech Republic seems a worthy accessory to Germany when considering property investments; especially with the current positive growth being seen.

Is The Worst Over For Central Europe’s Real Estate Markets?

Regional banks are still holding on to vulnerable real estate, with investors eagerly waiting in the wings to purchase from them.

Central European cities have seen huge development since 2000. Many cities had demand for dwellings outstripping supply. New properties were built and property prices shot up disproportionately. Speculative construction was supported by banks’ new expansionary policies.

Enormous real estate projects appeared, especially in the residential market, where the balance of quality and price became disrupted. Panic buying saw prices spiral out of control, with buyers assuming the growth would never stop. This is a similar pattern to what was seen across Europe.

The difference comes in 2008. Whilst Western Europe was pulled into the ‘credit crisis’, Central Europe carried on optimistically. By the end of 2008 there had been a split even in Central Europe . Poland started to struggle, whereas Slovakia, Hungary and the Czech Republic were still relatively strong markets. By 2010 foreign investor confidence in Central Europe fell and 70% of all real estate investments in Czech Republic were from locals.

During the last decade we have learned that Western Europe’s real estate market development is not a blue-print for Central Europe. There are huge differences between major cities and the national averages in Central Europe; much more so than in the West. You also have more distinct cultural differences between Central and Western Europe: Communism has gone but its mark will be left for a long time.

The crisis has left behind a number of failed and unfinished projects. These failures are still being upheld by the banks. This is the kind of support that is not apparent in Western Europe, were banks are failing and such projects go with them. This Central European market is waiting to go live once again.

Data for 2011 shows clear signs of recovery. Vacancy rates are declining, nominal rents are not significantly different, successful projects were completed and new ones initiated, whilst companies have learned very quickly to live in this new reality. For Central Europe most companies hadn’t gone so far forward that they couldn’t easily go back.

2011 also saw a significant increase in foreign investment once more, primarily from Americans, Germans and Brits. What is also clear is that the markets have returned to being moderate and stable.

Developers are now trying new strategies. Housing for the elderly and students is now something they are trying. Following the period of 1990-2000 were most social housing was sold off, there is a need for these kinds of projects. Developers are also building new social housing, bringing a modern approach on a traditional idea. Such schemes have proven very popular across Western Europe and the same is expected here.

Where recovery has not yet happened is in quality design and construction. Growth in Central and Eastern Europe has been outpacing the rate at which infrastructure can be rebuilt. This has led to poor quality design and construction, especially with funds hard to come by. Focus is now on trying not to sacrifice quality, especially in an area which had some of the finest craftsmen of the early 20th Century.

 

 

 

 

 

Another Interest Rate Record Low

It was only June when we announced that interest rates had dropped to a record low of 0.5%. Two months on, the vote on interest rates was very tight, slightly opposed to a drop. Now October is here and the expected change has come: Interest rates have dropped to 0.25%.

The retail banking market has yet to really respond. Many banks have not even fully responded to June’s cuts. Now with a further cut we are likely to see retail banks getting in real competition over the next couple of months. LBBW responded in September to June’s cuts, putting the benchmark at 2.39% VAR. There are more isolated incidences of sub 2% rates. These are only where banks backing large developments that are not selling. They are keen to  offload and spread debts to reduce their risks.

We don’t expect sub 2% rates to stay isolated, however. Widespread sub 2% variable products are realistic before the end of the year. We also expect fixed term products hitting the 2.5% mark. Whether refinancing or buying with a mortgage, it is an exciting time to be in the market.

Czech Republic Considers Re-Opening Gold Mines

We often say that the Czech Republic is a gold mine, but in this case we are talking about a real-life gold mine.

Increasing gold prices has caused the Czech Republic to consider re-opening its gold mine, closed since 1994. Gold prices have increased 5-fold since 2002. These price increases have caused several companies apply for licenses for exploration. One mine is of particular interest, Kašperské Hory, the countries largest. Its deposits are valued at 130Billion CZK.

Across the whole country there is thought to be around 400Billion CZK of unmined gold under the surface. This is one of the largest existing deposits in Europe.

Certain analysts rightfully believe that opening the mines would be a huge economic benefit for the country. It would provide both jobs and much needed tax revenue. The only thing stopping the opening mines is likely to be ecological protests. Fears of heavy industry destroying the ecology in protected areas is a real issue. Modern biological mining methods could be the answer, but we could still be a few years away from implementation.

Regardless, this story has certainly fuelled a sense of financial security amongst local residents.

September Newsletter – Currency and its effects

Currency rates have always been monitored, traded and used as a barometer for economic data.  And why wouldn’t they?  The world behaves as one market trading in numerous currencies.  However, at this stage, currency markets seem a very volatile place.  An issue not lost on concerned foreign investors. The euro zone continues to garner the most attention across all of Europe, even those outside the EU and euro zone.  This includes the Czech Republic as President Klaus this week in Italy reinforced his country’s desire to not adopt the euro.  Investment Solutions decided to report on the current situation; the future and the effects of currency exchange on Czech property investments.

To say the foreign exchange markets are confusing at the moment is an understatement.  Any number of potential outcomes exist depending on government policy, commodity prices, retail behaviour, weather, corporate confidence and even Apple.  Recently the dollar fell hard as a result of a third round of quantitative easing.  The euro has remained steady, but could face a similar fate to the dollar if the ECB’s new bond buying program (OMT) is needed in Madrid and Rome.  And despite recession in the UK, British sterling has gained steadily against the euro throughout 2012.  The Czech koruna (CZK) has fluctuated constantly this calendar year (a microcosm of the currency trade), but has risen slowly and steadily against the euro and GBP for the past decade.

The CZK has two weighty advantages: it is strongly linked to the euro; more specifically, Germany and northern Europe, and it is a single currency.  This is why the economic crisis failed to greatly affect the Czech Republic.  A growing German economy could still afford to buy Czech goods with euros and a single currency banking system (99% of public debt is in CZK) shielded Czechs from the world’s shrinking supply of funds.  But what will happen next?

The short term is anyone’s guess.  As previously mentioned, currencies remain frustratingly volatile.  However, the long term will continue to show a steady rise in the CZK against the euro and GBP.  The current state of the euro zone is holding the CZK back.  A break up of the euro, a Greek exit or a strengthening euro zone will all result in a long term strong CZK.  It is clear to see why the Czech’s remain hesitant about joining the euro zone.

What does it all mean for UK investors?

Currently, the CZK is much weaker than its mid-2011 peak.  Today’s rate of 30.5CZK/GBP now vs 26.5CZK/GBP then equates to approximately 15% difference in one year.  In real estate terms, that is 15% less profit if sold today vs mid-2011 if bought and sold in GBP and those profits returned to the UK.  However it means more for you money in terms of monthly rental profits in CZK (It is similar but less harsh for those whom invested in euros).  An investor looking to sell may want to remain cautious on when they sell or, more importantly, when they send the proceeds home.

Similarly a weak CZK provides more opportunity to an investor.  The Prague property market, once over supplied, has bottomed out and last month showed signs of a recovery.  An investment now will take advantage of low prices and future strengthening of the CZK.  Again, a return to mid-2011 currency levels provide a 15% gain, even if the market locally stagnates.  In both cases, for old and new investors, last months news of a market upturn makes for an additional bonus.

Case Study

We at ISG have helped a lot of clients understand their equity in GBP or Euros. It can be quite confusing. Many people think that because a flat bought for £50.000 is now worth £90.000, a £40.000 profit has been made. It depends on how much equity a client has within that property. If the client bought in cash, they will have made a huge gain and the above example is likely to be true. The great news for them is that they only pay capital gains on the local gain. Profits due to changes in exchange rates are not taxable.

Let’s take a standard situation of a client who bought a flat for 2.000.000Kc 5 years ago. They borrowed 85% so they put in 300.000Kc. That was at a rate of 42CZK/GBP. So in GBP they invested £7.150. That property is now worth 2.700.000Kc. That is capital appreciation of 700.000Kc, plus 200.000Kc paid off of their mortgage, plus the original 300.000Kc deposit. Altogether they have 1.200.000Kc in equity. This is the part they would actually receive back if sold now and at 30CZK/GBP, that is £40.000.

Locally, they have no capital gains tax to pay as they have kept the unit for 5 years. If and when moving the money back to the UK they are going to need to declare it. The gain was 700.000Kc locally. HMRC would see that at today’s value of say £23.333 less legitimate set-up costs. The client’s allowance is £10.600 per year, so they can bring it back gradually to avoid tax. If they were married they could bring it all back in one year tax free.

If that investment had been in cash without a mortgage, then that gain would have been huge. An initial purchase price of £48.000 and a sale value of £90.000 means a £42.000 gain and the great news is that the capital gain according to HMRC would be the same £23.333.

The power of investing in regions where the currency is strengthening is clear for all to see. Large deposits may not always make for high returns, but when currency is the main driver it really does.

If you would like help or advice on currency and investments, please get in touch.

Mortgage Market Heats Up As Banks Lower Rates and Criteria

September has finally brought some long anticipated interest rate cuts. These rates come after the reduction in base from 0.75% to 0.5% set in June by the Czech National Bank. Those who were lucky enough to be on variable rates had already seen similar drops on their August statements, but now everyone can get in on the action.

LBBW is keen to take a larger share of the mortgage market and has dropped its headline rate to 2.39%. This is the first time the 2.5% barrier has really been broken. Critics argue that their strict lending criteria is causing a false economy, but those who meet it are of course delighted with the rates.

Banks are becoming more innovative when it comes to interest rate discounts. Critics again argue that the products are becoming misleading. What is true is that clients are being confused by banks on what the best deals. It is important more than ever to use an experienced broker who can advise on what works best.

Some banks are less drawn into a direct rate war and are reducing criteria. Many banks are now offering refinancing without proof of income and some even without a valuation. They are simply taking up mortgage once agreed by another bank, assuming their risk department was competent. It may seem like risky business, but this is a well controlled low-risk banking system. In fact it is just great news for those with mortgages who no longer meet standard banking criteria.

As an expert broker Investment Solutions as always is on hand to give advice to clients about the best new mortgage products, both for purchases and for refinancing. 

Plans for Redevelopment on Hold at Derelict Freight Station

Prague’s ‘Nakladovy Nadrazi’ in Zizkov was abandoned over 10 years ago. The prime site, close to the development Central Park and just a stone’s through is prime land. It is one of the largest areas for redevelopment for its proximity to the centre. Sekyra, developer of our sales project Rezidence Korunni has been trying to turn this site into a modern multi-functional space for a decade. Plans include grade-A office buildings, a shopping centre, residential developments and even a new metro station. Essentially they would produce a modern living and working environment for 15.000 people.

Last week the local council decided to enter into another study for the site after protests from conservationists. They argue the site is of historical importance and more work should be done to conserve existing structures in the redevelopment, rather than flattening it. Sekyra’s architects argue that much work would need to be done to use the existing structures, built nearly 80 years ago, in order to be altered. They suggest grants from the city would be needed in order to do this. Many other architects argue that the structures have little historical importance. They comment that better examples are already preserved in Prague.

This debate looks to rumble on for a little longer, but it is clear that redevelopment will happen in some guise soon, which excellent news for those who have invested in the area or plan to soon.

The full article posted by Prague Post is available here.