The first quarter of 2013 ends this week. Early numbers from the Czech Statistical Office and Czech Central Bank indicate a 7th consecutive quarter of economic contraction, the longest in Czech history. Like many countries around the globe, Czech decision makers must determine what action is needed, if any, to curb this ongoing recession. Already, the Czech Central Bank has cut the benchmark rate to near zero to 0.05% and a Thursday meeting will be held to determine if currency intervention (currency trade – selling the CZK) is the required next step. The Czech koruna (CZK) has fallen 4.4% against the euro (€) since September but a further drop may be needed to boost trade and slow inflation.
Interestingly the above listed numbers, while important, do not tell the whole story. The Czech recession is driven largely by the drop in Czech consumer activity, not EU worries or a collapsing banking culture. Czech wages actually increased in 2012 but an increase in consumer spending did not mirror the improvement. In addition, unemployment across the country at 7.1% sits outside of the critical zone. Czechs simply choose to save. CNB governor Miroslav Singer had these comments in the Wall Street Journal last week:
Given that people save more, according to statistics, their total incomes should be higher, they definitely have enough money. It’s meaningful to ask for people to spend. If we would see deposits of people slowing down or declining then I would start having doubts what could be achieved. But at this particular moment, it’s quite obvious that the money is there. The population is not overly in debt, the statistics are OK, people are just sceptical.
Fuel for the Fire
Savvy investors in the US ignored the doom and gloom headlines and ineptitude of American politicians in 2012. Instead, we focused on a glaring statistic: approximately $500 billion had been yanked out of the US equity markets between 2010 – 2012. That’s $500 billion NOT circulating through the markets effectively undervaluing equities. A number of similar examples occurred across Europe as well. The now famously known action of quantitative easing, in part, derived from this phenomenon to infuse markets with more cash. The Dow Jones sits 11% higher in 2013 in large part because increased economic confidence has led investors to add $21 billion to the US stock market this year. Much more fuel for the fire still resides on the sideline. The situation across the Czech Republic is not dissimilar. Enough fuel sits on the sideline ready to burn. A change in confidence is needed.
Bottomed-Out Prices and Huge Supply
As expected, nearly 20,000 new flats have been completed in the past six months. Raw estimates put between 170,000 – 200,000 available flats for sale throughout the Czech Republic. The huge supply has not helped prices, but with new developments and construction now in decline previous estimates of a bottomed-out market seem to be correct. In Prague, demand and prices have risen steadily in the more sought after neighbourhoods of Prague 2 and 6 and the up and coming areas of Holesovice, Vrsovice and Nusle have witnessed the highest growth in demand in 2013.
What This Means for an Investor
Collectively, we at ISG believe no greater buyers market can exist. We continue to urge current investors to take advantage of the bank rates and refinance. In addition, new investors and re-investors should seriously consider the Prague market. If the CNB decides to intervene on the CZK then a greater window of opportunity will arise. A weakened CZK allows for an even cheaper entry for a foreign investor. From there, a strengthening CZK will result in more gains.
The standard theory states to wait for the beginning of a recovery before market re-entry. Will you be too late?